Jump to content
Mopar1973Man.Com LLC

  • Welcome To Mopar1973Man.Com LLC

    We are a privately owned support forum for the Dodge Ram Cummins Diesels. All information is free to read for everyone. To interact or ask questions you must have a subscription plan to enable all other features beyond reading. Please go over to the Subscription Page and pick out a plan that fits you best. At any time you wish to cancel the subscription please go back over to the Subscription Page and hit the Cancel button and your subscription will be stopped. All subscriptions are auto-renewing. 

VP44 PSG fuel cooler ideas

KATOOM
 Share

Recommended Posts

rancherman

rancherman

Posted
Posted (edited)

Rancherman...How is the "new" pump working.

Chris

I got the  SO  version,  and   it's  been  'perfect'.    (no problems!)     Been  running   2 stroke, about  75% of the time..   

The lift pump was  a    drrp  when I  put the new  VP in...  which   took a  dump  4 months  later...(between the  ice in the fuel, and   subzero temps with  #2 fuel in the tank... It  just  'gave up'...(lift pump)

So  I  put in a   Fass  drp 2.    So far so good.

You may get it  quicker than you think!   I ordered it...assuming it'd  ship from  Utah,  but  it actually came  from Illinois.    Took  3 days!     I  think I  had  30 days  to  ship  the core back to them..

Edited by rancherman
Link to comment
Share on other sites
MnTom

MnTom

Posted
Posted

excuse my ignorance, im usually really good at acronyms but whats does PSG stand for Pump S? G?    :doh:

Just hover your cursor over the acronim and it will tell you.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
KATOOM

KATOOM

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Found out some more information about the PSG.  So far no one can tell me why the PSG fails.  Thats the million dollar mystery question apparently.....  The concept was tossed out there that maybe it pertains to how the older PSG's were manufactured but other than that there's no understanding why one component would be more problematic over another. 

 

In regards to Bosch.....  Bosch is no longer building VP44 housings but are still producing PSG's, which is where these new PSG's are supposedly coming from.  The PSG's also must be synced with the VP in order to function properly which is why the 1/4 million dollar test bench is necessary.  PSG number 029 and 030 are supposed to be an industrial version but only meaning they wont work on the Dodge Cummins VP.  I cant confirm whether or not either of those have Pb solder though.

 

Also something very interesting and potentially useful for some people is that the first 10 digits under the PSG bar code are the model version.  If you have the numbers 0 281 010 890 then you have the most updated PSG available by Bosch, which has been around for at least 5 - 6 years since I have that code and I bought my pump in late 2008.  But if the last digits are 827 then you have the older version PSG which may have been reused on a re-manufactured VP simply because it still worked.  But.....that said, I could still see where someone who just bought a VP could have a 890 PSG which was still reused.

Edited by KATOOM
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites
snowshoveler

snowshoveler

Posted
Posted

Well...I went and did a bit of homework myself. My VP44 died last week with a  P1688 code.

I found very little info about that other than Mike says its the failure of the solder in the electrics of the PSG.

I sort of feel okay with that. I always wonderd how the truck was treated before I got it. Wondered about fuel and heat.

I am carefull with fuel and set the edge to shut off when it cools to 300 degrees.

...Hmmm if its electric, i should send my core to Mike... he has a nasty pump with a gooder PSG than mine.

Regards Chris

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rancherman

rancherman

Posted
Posted

I think the million dollar question would be..

After the   transistor  has  become  'desoldered'...     has it (the  transistor)  been  tested afterward  for  faults???   Did it fail,  got hot, THEN melted away? Or are they  perfectly good,   only needing  resoldered?

 

What exactly is  a  transistor?   

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KATOOM

KATOOM

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

A transistor is basically an amplifier taking a smaller signal and turning it into a stronger signal.  There are also transistors which work like on/off switches too, and really.....I have no idea what type of transistor is in the PSG or what its true purpose is in there.  But because transistors are generally amplifiers, this is why some people (including me) feel that there's a reason the transistor fails and potentially that cause is amplification of voltage from some unknown source or reason.  Like maybe the process of starting the engine is very taxing on the PSG transistor while it takes in a large surge of voltage as the ECM instructs the VP to begin the fueling process.  Thus the "starting cycle" we all know about.  Or maybe the the transistor is merely overloaded period.  Maybe there needs to be some kind of capacitor wired in or maybe the VP power supply shouldn't be coming from the ECM but rather from a direct 12 volt source via a relay.  Again.....I dont know but I'm betting someone somewhere knows. :smart:

Edited by KATOOM
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Ilikeoldfords

Ilikeoldfords

Posted
Posted

Could the transistors be getting cooked because of things like high AC voltage from the alternator? I am not sure how the current flows through the PSG but that might explain why Mike's is outlasting a lot of others. He keeps good track of the AC voltage, not to mention everything else.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Owner
Mopar1973Man

Mopar1973Man

Posted
  • Owner
Posted

I think transistor damage is partially AC noise and poor electronics (modules). I still can't see 130*F being a issue for transistor. I've seen amplifiers get quite hot. CPU in a normal every day PC is loaded with thousands transistors. Both AMD and Intel processors will run upwards of 160-180*F on a full load run. So why does a simple single transistor fail in a PSG unit at low temps (not enough to trip the P0168 code). The only other thing is maybe the early years Bosch used margin transistors in the manufacture and they couldn't tolerate the load and POOF! So now they have updated the transistors to to tolerate loads of the VP44 solenoids.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
KATOOM

KATOOM

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Maybe you're right Mike.  Maybe the updated computers do have better components.....just like the rest of the VP received over the years.  Strangely though, I clearly and without a doubt remember Chip telling me a couple years ago that Bosch upgraded to a larger heatsink for better PSG heat dissipation but when asking other (just as reputable) venders they say they've never heard of that.  So.....who's right?  Well since I've never seen a picture of a VP which doesnt look like any other bazillion VP's I've seen on the internet, I would have to say assume that there's been no heatsink change.

 

But I also agree with you in that there's no reason running temperatures should ever affect the PSG.  Even heat cycle temperatures shouldn't cause a problem since anything I find says that the lowest melting temps for tin solder are around no less than 400* F.....and thats on the cold side since optimal solder gun tips run in the 600*-700* range.

 

I'm beginning to think that the "heat cycle" theory is just that.....a theory.  Potentially bogus too.  Just like the dreaded torn or cracked diaphragm theory which seemingly plagues every VP that lands on the bench of a VP supplier.  Especially if its a warranty item.  A knee-jerk response we still see it floating around forums like its fact too and is the main cause of all VP problems.  Its almost like the FDA is helping Bosch come up with things to tell everyone.....

 

There's a reason the PSG fails.  Is it heat or is it surges of electricity?  It sure would be nice if we could find out. :shrug:   It only took around 10 years for someone to volunteer a VP core.  Maybe it wont take another decade before someone with some serious electronic skills can figure this out.  Thats not to say Mike isnt an electronic guru either. :hug:

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rancherman

rancherman

Posted
Posted

Yea I got a spare VP44 on the shelf ready for tear down. Its a 027 Rev pump so its the newest out.

 

I know the one I sent back in to get the core charge  would've been perfect...   OEM  2000,      99%  sure it was   PSG   related,      *oh,  If  I only knew  that  saving a  few hundred bucks*     or    "the  burden on  ONE  is  good  for  the benefit of many"  ...  sigh,

 

OK,   so  'transistor'      (transformer-resistor)  correct??

 

It'd  be  REALLY   informative  on how that lil dude    works  in the system...     what's it  doing  at various  stages  of  operation of the engine:   Is it going nuts  when  accelerating,    or  is it  when    it's  holding  max   timing..    or  perhaps    a  start-up   loop.     

Maybe the  dang thing  just  sits  there and  hums,   supplying the  rest of the board  with a constant    type  of current... 

 

So,   a  test mule   (vp)  without an engine to  run it  ( I suppose this is  where  those   high dollar test benches  come in handy)     probably  won't  help much  on   finding  'how'  that transistor  works  within the  system.

 

although,  it'd  sure  be nice to  find  a vp with   desoldered  transistor,     remove it,    and  test it to  find out if it's  still   within it's  parameters...       I'm assuming  they  are  externally marked  (like  a  resistor. "stripes, numbers" )  so  a  person  could look up  the values they are rated at?    

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
KATOOM

KATOOM

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Does anyone know if you can remove the PSG cover and replace the screws and still be able to run the engine?  I know there's an o-ring seal under there which must be held tight but my understanding is that no electronics are ever bathed in diesel.

 

Having the cover off would make it possible to view the circuitry of the PSG while the engine is running.  Not that you'd be able to watch anything as you're cruising down the road but you could certainly try to establish what happens during heat cycles and start up cycles and maybe even detect the temperature of certain portions of the circuit and the transistor.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...