I very much agree you and here is why. I am the original owner of my 2002 truck. The VP44 and lift pump were replaced in 2005 at 87,000 miles under warranty for timing piston failure code on the VP44.
The lift pump pressure was in specs before the VP44 and lift pump were replaced. I drove the truck for a week (50 miles per day before I gave the truck to the dealer)with a fuel gauge attached to my windshield wiper and the fuel pressure always stayed within specs under all driving conditions.
After the replacement of the VP44 and the factory modification of installing an in-tank lift pump, I installed the same fuel pressure gauge and fuel pressure was much lower than specs under all driving conditions (6 psi at idle and 3 psi under a load). I questioned the dealer mechanic (a very knowledgeable guy) about this and he said he is aware of this, but the new lift pump installation change is required by Dodge.
Fast forward a few years - I currently have 267,000 miles on the truck (180,000 miles on the replaced VP44). In the spring of 2016 (at 251,000 miles) I replaced the in-tank lift pump (which was still working) with a frame mounted used FASS lift pump. I only did this in case the lift pump failed while on a road trip which would make for an easy repair.
So the VP44 ran for 11 years and 164,000 miles with the in-tank lift pump operating at very low pressures and the VP44 is still running fine. Hmmmm....
Thanks for listening
- John