Muffler or resonator delete

[SilverMoose]

Going to head to a local muffler shop tomorrow to get either the muffler or resonator taken off my stock system. I assume it would be a better idea to delete the muffler and keep the resonator. I would appreciate some input on which to do and has anyone done this. I just want to get a little more sound out of my truck but not have too much in cab drone. A friend did both and the sound is nice. But the best part is the cost. They only charged him 80 bucks to do both plus a chrome tip.  Can't even get a muffler delete pipe online for that price. 

 

Thanks in advance.

 

L8tr

D

[Mopar1973Man]

Ive enjoyed my straight through muffled 3 inch exhaust. Now I've got a diamond eye 4 inch exhaust with flow through muffled its not loud in the cab but the drone is louder now than the old 3 inch. I ran straight pipe 3 inch for years no issues for drone but it was loud. Everyone knew when I was coming home.

[CTcummins24V]

Cut it off yourself and buy some strap clamps and 3” pipe for $30

[Dieselfuture]

I can't comment on 3 inch I got my truck with a 5 inch and a see-through Muffler don't even know what brand. It's fairly quiet in the cab on long trips drone is fine unless I get over 75 mph, which I rarely do.

[Sycostang67]

If it's too loud, you're not old enough.....to have lost enough of your hearing so that it doesn't bother you. 

[Tom Robarts]

I had 4" with a muffler, straight pipe and now 4" straight with 6" stacks.  I don't find it real loud.  Cann' t carry a conversation on in the cab.  I ran a 671 Detroit with a straight pipe in a fishing boat for years so I'm GM deaf anyways

[notlimah]

Cousin has 4in with resonator almost at the downpipe and it sounds amazing. Pretty tame at idle, definitely know it’s there when you hit the gas, but drone is gone.

[Michaelsloft]

3 minutes ago, notlimah said:

Cousin has 4in with resonator almost at the downpipe and it sounds amazing

Do you happen to know the manufacturer of the resonator and the length? 

 

[CUMMINSDIESELPWR]

mine is straight piped, 3" not that loud unless i hammer on it  no drone either

[trreed]

Mine is also straight 4". However, I have a variant of a resonator before the downpipe that quiets it down real nice. Almost like I got it at Target.  Almost. 

Edited April 21, 2018 by trreed

[notlimah]

29 minutes ago, Michaelsloft said:

Do you happen to know the manufacturer of the resonator and the length? 

 

 

30in FTE on a diamond eye

 

3 minutes ago, trreed said:

Mine is also straight 4". However, I have a variant of a resonator before the downpipe that quiets it down real nice. Almost like I got it at Target.  Almost. 

 

You don’t count, you have twins so it’s quieter!!

[Michaelsloft]

2 minutes ago, notlimah said:

30in FTE on a diamond eye

Thanks! 

[trreed]

26 minutes ago, notlimah said:

You don’t count, you have twins so it’s quieter!!

Compounds ?. Its not quiet when you lay into it!

Edited April 21, 2018 by trreed

[notlimah]

Don’t get technical!

[SilverMoose]

Thanks guys, I appreciate all your responses. I will update when I get back later.

 

L8tr

D

[KATOOM]

I deleted the stock muffler, then later the resonator.  So cool sounding I didnt care about the drone until a couple years later when it finally got the best of me...  So in attempt to fix it based on the guitar string concept of drone, I rednecked a T post to my exhaust with hose clamps where the muffler used to be and it changed the tone of the drone to a much more tolerable level.  I still thought the straight pipe stock exhaust (which isnt 3" but more like 2.75") was too raspy sounding, but low on my priority list of things to care about.

 

Then I started pulling a heavy 5th wheel toy hauler and noticed that my EGT's were hard to keep in check.  So I upgrading to a 4" without a muffler.  The EGT's were better and the overall tone of the exhaust was better sounding too.  The drone is still there but not annoying enough yet.

 

I "may" look into sticking a FTE under there somewhere but really I just dont feel like messing with it.  Man.....I sure made myself sound lazy.

Edited April 21, 2018 by KATOOM

[Michaelsloft]

20 minutes ago, KATOOM said:

I deleted the stock muffler, then later the resonator.  So cool sounding I didnt care about the drone until a couple years later when it finally got the best of me

When you deleted the muffler, but left the resonator was the sound "raspy" too or just louder?  I'm thinking the resonator might reduce the higher frequency sounds that tend to be raspy.  It is difficult to communicate all the intangibles of sound and noise levels etc, but raspy is a good way to describe some of the exhaust sounds! 

I'm still running the stock original exhaust and may have to make some changes soon due to oxidation starting where in the mid-pipe goes into the muffler.....now that is lazy not making any changes for 19 years!

Have heard good things about the quality of sound from the FTE mufflers and resonators but have no personal experience, so anything you can share is appreciated and helpful.

Thank you.....

 

Edited April 21, 2018 by Michaelsloft
Typo

[KATOOM]

When I first deleted the muffler the sound was probably what I should have stuck with.  Mellow but louder.  I honestly dont remember there being any drone with the resonator still on there either but the time frame between having the muffler removed to when I had the resonator taken out was probably only a few months...  I drove with it straight piped for about 12 years until I installed the 4" exhaust.

[Michaelsloft]

4 minutes ago, KATOOM said:

When I first deleted the muffler the sound was probably what I should have stuck with.  Mellow but louder. 

hmmm....makes sense.  Did you find the 4" exhaust note to be deeper along with the raspy higher tones?  And with a resonator the 4" might be the best way to go for overall performance gains and sound quality.  

[KATOOM]

The 4" sounds much better in all aspects.  The "raspy" sound is gone and replaced with a deeper tone.  Again, the only reason I bothered to install a 4" was because the EGT's were too hot for me on hills while towing.  Only after removing the stock exhaust did I realize how small it was.....and smashed in various locations from the pinch bending and clamps used at the factory.  The pictures explain best.

 

 

Edited April 21, 2018 by KATOOM